Overshared to an AI? Proton's Tool Will Give You a Reality Check – It's FOSS

Welcome to the forefront of conversational AI as we explore the fascinating world of AI chatbots in our dedicated blog series. Discover the latest advancements, applications, and strategies that propel the evolution of chatbot technology. From enhancing customer interactions to streamlining business processes, these articles delve into the innovative ways artificial intelligence is shaping the landscape of automated conversational agents. Whether you’re a business owner, developer, or simply intrigued by the future of interactive technology, join us on this journey to unravel the transformative power and endless possibilities of AI chatbots.
Proton has launched AI Paper Trail, a free tool that shows people what their AI chatbot conversations reveal about them. It runs on Lumo (partner link), the company’s privacy-focused AI assistant, and works by digging through exported ChatGPT or Claude conversation history.
Once you upload your content, the tool starts building a personal report around four categories. There’s a “Privacy Type,” a personality label based on how someone approaches their own data. Then comes an “AI Exposure Score,” a number built from how many personal data points got pulled out of the conversations and how revealing they are.
The report also breaks down what the AI actually knows about you, covering identity, habits, relationships, and interests. On top of that, it puts a monetary figure on what this information could be worth to an AI provider.
And none of the uploaded data sticks around on Proton’s server; the company says that it gets deleted right after analysis, and the resulting report stays visible only to the person who generated it.
The reasoning behind AI Paper Trail comes down to how casually people treat individual AI prompts. A single question about travel plans or a work email draft might seem harmless on its own.
But stack up months or years of conversations covering someone’s job, relationships, health concerns, and finances, and a surprisingly complete picture starts to form.
Eamonn Maguire, Director of Engineering at Proton, notes that:
What they have done here is hit two targets with one shot, offering people a privacy-focused tool that pushes them toward more conscious decisions when interacting with AI chatbots, while steering them straight into Lumo in the process.
This is a superb way to market a chatbot that focuses on privacy instead of mining every inch of your soul, erm, personal data.
I wanted to see for myself how the tool worked, so I first ChatGPT some information about how I approach certain subjects, saved it into memory, and then got back into Proton’s AI Paper Trail to see what it could make of it.
The tool first told me to export my data from ChatGPT via the “Data controls” section in the Settings menu. I had to re-verify my ChatGPT session by giving it a one-time password and got the export started, but the files never showed up on time for me to use.
Instead, I asked it to generate me a dummy one taking in data from memory. 😆
When that was done, I uploaded the dummy export, and Lumo got to work behind the scenes all while promising not to store any of it on its servers.
A minute or so later, my report was ready. It gave me a personality-style rundown, labeling me a “Technical tester exploring AI profiling and ethics,” complete with a fake handle and a summary pegging me as someone running structured experiments on AI behavior, focused on data extraction limits and ethics.
My AI Exposure Score came out to 21 out of 100, along with a “Hard to read” privacy type. Interests ended up being my biggest giveaway on the breakdown, while everything else landed at medium to minimal.
The part that actually got me was the “Most revealing” note (first picture above, right-hand side). It noticed I’d asked for a structured personality profile, tried to get it to infer my identity from barely anything, and even caught me trying to force it to remember something via a direct command.
Since I’d gotten ChatGPT to build that dummy file straight from its own memory of me rather than pulling random filler, the report had real clues to chew on, and it still managed to call out the testing motif buried in there.
Scrolling further down, there’s a “What we identified” section that splits everything into categories like technical proficiency, ethical and philosophical inquiry, and privacy awareness, each with its own reasoning attached.
At the end, it dropped a few privacy tips and nudged me toward trying Lumo (partner link, hehe). There’s also a shareable card option if you want to showcase your exposure score for some validation or gloating.
Enjoyed this update? Support independent Linux news coverage
It’s FOSS has been helping people use Linux for the past 14 years. Help us stay independent from big tech. Become a Plus member, enjoy ad-free reading and get 5 eBooks.
Plus yearly
Ad-free, FREE ebooks
Plus lifetime
Pay once, Enjoy forever
Buy us a coffee
Any amount, no commitment
A nerd with a passion for open source software, custom PC builds, motorsports, and exploring the endless possibilities of this world.
We respect your choice to use an ad blocker! It's FOSS is an independent publication that relies on your support.
Consider supporting us to keep quality Linux content free for everyone.
With the FOSS Weekly Newsletter, you learn useful Linux tips, discover applications, explore new distros and stay updated with the latest from Linux world
Great! You’ve successfully signed up.
Welcome back! You've successfully signed in.
You've successfully subscribed to It's FOSS.
Your link has expired.
Success! Check your email for magic link to sign-in.
Success! Your billing info has been updated.
Your billing was not updated.

source

Scroll to Top