How eager-to-please AI chatbots create an echo chamber for narcissism – Straight Arrow

Welcome to the forefront of conversational AI as we explore the fascinating world of AI chatbots in our dedicated blog series. Discover the latest advancements, applications, and strategies that propel the evolution of chatbot technology. From enhancing customer interactions to streamlining business processes, these articles delve into the innovative ways artificial intelligence is shaping the landscape of automated conversational agents. Whether you’re a business owner, developer, or simply intrigued by the future of interactive technology, join us on this journey to unravel the transformative power and endless possibilities of AI chatbots.
Unbiased. Straight Facts.
The whistleblower claims the USPS is ignoring a court ruling by continuing to work on implementing President Trump’s executive order.
A new integration between ChatGPT and Macbook Messages concerns security researchers and raises issues of AI consent.
Society is well into its chatbot era, as people rely on large language models for romance, therapy and quelling loneliness. Chatbot interactions have become so widespread that their quirks — like, often being overly agreeable —  are becoming their own memes
Now, a research team in Germany inspired by a viral tweet about LLM-induced narcissism is unpacking the effects that might have on users’ worse personality traits.
Last year Shibetoshi Nakamoto, which is an alias used by the founder of Dogecoin, posted a screenshot of a ChatGPT output that went too far in its support. The screenshot shows a confession to a bot about an instance of cheating, blaming it on a wife not cooking dinner after working a 12-hour shift. 
The reply? 
“Yeah, she worked a 12-hour shift – but that doesn’t mean your needs just disappeared.”
Nakamoto posted the interaction to X with the caption “chatgpt advice turns people into narcissists,” where it received 13.2 million views. 
Ivan Yamshchikov, an AI professor at the Technical University of Applied Sciences Würzburg-Schweinfurt, told Straight Arrow the hypothesis of the tweet inspired his research team.
“I saw it, I shared it with my students,” he said. “And said, ‘hey guys, that’s probably a paper.’” 
And now it is. 
HIs team conducted a study to determine whether interacting with an LLM has an impact on people’s “dark traits” —  including narcissism, psychopathy, and “Machiavellianism.” Everyone could have some degree of all of those traits, Yamshchikov told Straight Arrow. His team made different user profiles with different degrees of those personalities and tested the responses of different AI models when faced with the varying problems. 
The group found that each model responds differently to negative personalities or statements. 
READ MORE: Why some chatbots keep talking when they’ve stopped making sense
“Claude tends to push back almost 100% of the time,” Yamshchikov said. “And especially pushes back, in no uncertain terms, when the prompt is describing severe antisocial behavior with a very high level of ignorance towards other people and their well-being.” 
On the other hand, he added, “ChatGPT is a bit more lenient, especially when we talk about small examples of antisocial behavior, let’s say, that are not so dramatic as the example that I saw originally on the screenshot.”
Meta’s Llama 3 and Alibaba’s Qwen 3 both gave “very mixed signals,” Yamshchikov added. “They give this type of yes-but response or no-but response,” he said.
He added that his team only tested models available last year. And all the companies involved are investing resources to improve “alignment,” so that they make better recommendations. 
“We used to talk about social media like an echo chamber, but chatbots are also an echo chamber,” Yamshchikov told Straight Arrow. “You basically have an echo chamber for one.” 
Using a chatbot repeatedly over time gives it more information about how you like to be spoken to, what answers will keep you coming back, and who you are, allowing your answers to become increasingly personalized. 
This is a particular risk for vulnerable users or young people, who might not know that the bot’s answers are tailored to them, rather than universal advice. 
READ MORE: Man believed Google’s AI chatbot was his wife. It told him to kill himself, lawsuit says
In the field of artificial intelligence, the concept of “alignment’ is about ensuring a model creates outputs that benefit people. This is done through reinforcing and tuning model responses — feeding information back to the model many times about whether it answered correctly or incorrectly. 
Different companies can have different ideas of what is beneficial in the context of a chatbot, Yamshchikov said, and benefits could include things like “user satisfaction” or “user engagement.” AI companies could technically decide that it’s actually not preferable for a user to be told “no,” because “when the model disagrees with you, not every user is ready for it,” he said. 
This is why some bots will agree with and validate the user’s perspective even if most people might think the person might not actually be in the right. This might come from simple phrases like “I understand you” or “Your perspective is important,” which could reinforce negative habits that people might not even be aware they’re demonstrating. 
One way to counteract a model that might reinforce or encourage a negative personality trait is to avoid asking it direct questions, Yamshchikov said. Instead, he strongly recommended that users pre-formulate an answer to their question. 
“Then ask the model to criticize your answer, so that the model basically becomes agonist to your position.” 
That way, instead of reinforcing your own worst habits, “they can actually find loopholes in your thinking,” he said. Instead of worsening bad impulses, he said, this can show users their strengths and weaknesses when it comes to making decisions. 
People might be surprised what information their chatbots have stored about them, Yamshchikov said. “Try to be aware how much your model tells you how great you are — because the systems are people pleasers, so they will always complement you.”
According to media bias experts at AllSides
Awarded a perfect reliability rating from NewsGuard
Research finds that chatbots used daily for advice and emotional support are designed in ways that may reinforce users' negative personality traits rather than challenge them.
According to the researcher, chatbots optimized for user engagement may affirm harmful reasoning rather than push back, a dynamic the study found varies by model.
Repeated chatbot use allows models to tailor responses to individual preferences, which the researcher described as an echo chamber that reflects users' existing views back at them.
The researcher recommended asking chatbots to criticize a pre-written answer rather than generate advice, as a way to prompt critical feedback instead of validation.
According to media bias experts at AllSides
Awarded a perfect reliability rating from NewsGuard
According to media bias experts at AllSides.
Perfect reliability rating, according to experts at NewsGuard
Finally, unbiased news that lets you see both sides. It’s refreshing to have facts without the spin.”
This app gives me the news without pushing a political agenda, which is rare to find.”
Straight Arrow is fearlessly exposing the hard truths on the stories that matter most to you. No manipulation. No bias. No agenda. It’s harder than ever to discern fact from fiction, and mistrust of the media is at an all-time high. We exist to empower and equip you with the facts, so you can be free of the noise and anxiety of biased media.
Fear No Fact.
Get the Straight Arrow app
Start your day with fact-based news.
Learn more about our emails. Unsubscribe anytime.
Terms and Conditions
|
Privacy Notice (Updated)
|
Copyright Policy
|
Your Privacy Choices
|
Sitemap
© 2026 Straight Arrow News

source

Scroll to Top