Americans cautious with AI for finances but open to political influence – The Journal Record

Welcome to the forefront of conversational AI as we explore the fascinating world of AI chatbots in our dedicated blog series. Discover the latest advancements, applications, and strategies that propel the evolution of chatbot technology. From enhancing customer interactions to streamlining business processes, these articles delve into the innovative ways artificial intelligence is shaping the landscape of automated conversational agents. Whether you’re a business owner, developer, or simply intrigued by the future of interactive technology, join us on this journey to unravel the transformative power and endless possibilities of AI chatbots.
2026 Journal Record Health Care Heroes

By : Heide Brandes//The Journal Record//January 1, 2026//
Studies suggest that people are more inclined to believe information from artificial intelligence pertaining to political opinions than they are to allow an AI chatbot to manage their 401(k). Shown here is a graphic illustration of the Meta logo and CEO Mark Zuckerberg (Deposit Photos)
Americans cautious with AI for finances but open to political influence
Studies suggest that people are more inclined to believe information from artificial intelligence pertaining to political opinions than they are to allow an AI chatbot to manage their 401(k). Shown here is a graphic illustration of the Meta logo and CEO Mark Zuckerberg (Deposit Photos)

By : Heide Brandes//The Journal Record//January 1, 2026//

When it comes to , Americans appear to have a split personality. While they listen to AI chatbots spin arguments about candidates and policy positions without blinking, they won’t let those same systems touch their 401(k)s without triple-checking with a human being first.
Two recent studies demonstrate this disconnect. A study published this month in the journal Science found that AI chatbots are effective at changing people’s political opinions, even when nearly one in five of their claims are factually wrong. Researchers from Oxford, Stanford, MIT and the UK’s AI Security Institute engaged nearly 77,000 participants with various AI chatbots tasked with changing their views on topics like taxes and immigration.

The AI systems frequently succeeded, and the effects lasted at least a month. Even more, the most persuasive chatbots tended to be the least accurate. About 19 percent of all AI claims were rated as “predominantly inaccurate.”
Yet when Americans are asked whether they’d let similar AI systems manage their , the response is a nearly unanimous “absolutely not.”
A new survey from InvestorsObserver of 1,050 experienced U.S. investors between 35 and 60 with portfolios of at least $500,000 found that 88 percent would refuse to let an AI chatbot manage their 401(k). Nearly two-thirds have never used AI for , and only 5 percent act on AI-generated financial recommendations without consulting a human first.

“People are open to using AI chatbots to generate ideas, but when it comes to life savings in 401(k)s and IRAs, they want a human hand on the wheel,” said Sam Bourgi, senior analyst at InvestorsObserver. “Today, AI can inform retirement decisions, but it should not replace personal judgment or professional advice.”
The paradox demonstrates how Americans demand verification when AI talks about their money but accept persuasion when AI talks about their democracy.
Money Talks, Politics Listens
Lisa Garrison, 36, of Chandler, sees the disparity clearly. She manages a small IRA with a financial advisor and actively avoids AI wherever possible.
“I don’t have anywhere near that kind of money, but I personally don’t trust AI at all,” Garrison said. “Generative AI has been notorious for making things up that sound true without being true. I don’t think AI should have any say in decisions that affect people’s livelihoods or lives.”
When asked why people might verify financial AI but accept political AI at face value, Garrison offered a theory that cuts to the heart of American culture.
“Money has a real, tangible, and immediate effect on people’s lives in that you can afford to pay the bills and eat, or you can’t,” she said. “When it comes to politics, we aren’t taught to consider political decisions in similar terms of real consequences. Most people treat their politics the same way they revere their inherited religious beliefs: as personal, unquestionable, and therefore correct.”
The Science study’s lead author, Oxford doctoral student Kobi Hackenburg, noted the same potential dangers.
“These results suggest that optimizing persuasiveness may come at some cost to truthfulness,” Hackenburg wrote, “a dynamic that could have malign consequences for public discourse.”
What We Verify Reveals What We Value
The contrast between these studies highlights American priorities, said Hackenburg. When bank accounts are on the line, people demand human oversight and expert verification. The InvestorsObserver survey found that 59 percent of investors plan to continue using AI for financial research, but most treat it as a starting point rather than a decision-maker.
Yet when democratic institutions are at stake, many consume AI-influenced content without the same scrutiny. Some 44 percent of U.S. adults now use AI tools like ChatGPT “sometimes” or “very often.” These same tools can shift political views with lasting effect, even when it provides misinformation.
Garrison connects this to recent political events.
“How many times have we seen large swaths of the population realize the consequences of their political choices only when it starts affecting them and their money?” she asked. “Farmers, federal workers, trade unions… it didn’t become real to them until it happened to them.”
The warning from the study’s authors is that highly persuasive AI chatbots “could benefit unscrupulous actors wishing to promote radical political or religious ideologies or foment political unrest.”
Meanwhile, the financial industry is settling into what Bourgi calls a “hybrid” model, using AI to surface ideas and flag risks while keeping humans in control of final decisions.
When Garrison was asked what her gut reaction would be if a financial app claimed to have analyzed 10,000 data points and recommended a move with her retirement savings, her answer was immediate.
“Rather predictably, I’m sure, my gut reaction would be to dismiss it out of hand.”


Share this!
Research shows that giving up on homeownership leads to less work effort, more luxury spending, and riskier in[…]
January 1, 2026
Funding cuts under President Trump threaten the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, risking protections for […]
January 1, 2026
Oklahoma tech leaders forecast AI-driven growth and workforce shifts in 2026, highlighting opportunities, chal[…]
December 29, 2025
Oklahoma homeowner insurance rates spark debate as PropFusion, NerdWallet report high costs, while state data […]
December 26, 2025
More than 17M U.S. workers teleworked in 2025 as companies hire for fully remote, work-from-anywhere jobs acro[…]
December 26, 2025
Rising homeowners insurance is erasing Oklahoma City’s affordability edge, with Tulsa faring slightly better, […]
December 26, 2025
Sign up for your daily digest of Oklahoma News.
Oklahoma’s prison population rises for third straight year as lawmakers enact tougher sentencing w[…]
The FBI sent additional investigators to Minnesota amid fraud probes that critics say unfairly targe[…]
Oklahoma farmer blocked from suing over $1M in soybean crop damage due to a little-known state law r[…]
Federal ruling on poultry pollution in the Illinois River Watershed draws sharp reactions from Oklah[…]
Arkansas regulators challenge Tulsa’s wastewater permit appeal over unlicensed lawyers and federal[…]
The Oklahoma Bar Association’s Indian Law Section has awarded $12,000 in scholarships to four law st[…]
Discover key business books for 2026 that cover personal finance, workplace authenticity, and family[…]
Oklahoma City and Tulsa offer free Christmas tree mulching through mid-January, with curbside option[…]
Tulsa’s Leviathan Robotics team is invited by Gov. Kevin Stitt to represent Oklahoma at the inaugu[…]
OKC Indian Clinic’s Warm & Fuzzy Program supports American Indian families with meals, toys, c[…]
U.S. government admits liability in January Black Hawk–American Airlines crash that killed 67 near[…]
Southwest Airlines expects Boeing 737 MAX 7 certification by August 2026, with flights to begin in e[…]
Oklahoma advances its space ambitions with a new hangar design contract and strategic planning tied […]
China and Brazil launch joint lab for space tech, supporting the BINGO telescope and deep-space rese[…]
Scientists discover the largest-known rotating cosmic filament, a 50M light-year structure of galaxi[…]
The Journal Record is an award-winning daily general business and legal publication that includes a daily print newspaper and a 24/7 website. Both focus on local and statewide business trends and in-depth stories that convey the voice of the Oklahoma business community.
Get our free e-alerts & breaking news notifications!
Subscribe for access to the latest digital and special editions.
© 2026 BridgeTower Media. All rights reserved.
Use of this website is subject to its Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Your California Privacy Rights/Privacy Policy | Do Not Sell My Info/Cookie Policy

source

Scroll to Top