Are you relying on AI chatbots for emotional support? Expert explains the risks of dependence and its impact on mental health | Health – Hindustan Times

Welcome to the forefront of conversational AI as we explore the fascinating world of AI chatbots in our dedicated blog series. Discover the latest advancements, applications, and strategies that propel the evolution of chatbot technology. From enhancing customer interactions to streamlining business processes, these articles delve into the innovative ways artificial intelligence is shaping the landscape of automated conversational agents. Whether you’re a business owner, developer, or simply intrigued by the future of interactive technology, join us on this journey to unravel the transformative power and endless possibilities of AI chatbots.
Subscribe Now! Get features like
As more young people turn to artificial intelligence (AI) chatbots for emotional support, concerns are growing about their impact on self-trust, relationships and emotional resilience. While chatbots offer an accessible, non-judgmental space to express feelings, relying on them for every difficult conversation or personal decision could make it harder to develop essential emotional skills.
Prakriti Saxena Poddar, clinically trained mental health and wellbeing expert and global head at Roundglass, shares with HT Lifestyle how excessive reliance on AI for emotional reassurance can affect psychological well-being and why these tools should complement, rather than replace, human connection. (Also read: Skin rashes in children: Paediatrician explains common causes, warning signs and when parents should worry )
While chatbots can provide temporary comfort, repeatedly turning to them for reassurance may reinforce anxiety. A person might feel better after receiving an answer, only to experience the same doubts again and return to the chatbot for relief.
“An anxious mind craves certainty. Reassurance delivers a little, and for a few minutes the sympathetic nervous system settles, the chest loosens, the loop goes quiet. Then the doubt returns, often louder, and the mind asks again,” Prakriti explains.
She emphasises that emotional resilience develops through everyday experiences, including navigating disagreements, making independent decisions and learning to sit with uncomfortable feelings.
“Emotional capacities are built through friction, the way muscle is built through resistance. Staying with an uncomfortable feeling for 10 minutes builds distress tolerance. Working out what you actually want builds self-trust. Repairing a quarrel builds confidence in your relationships,” she says.
The concern, therefore, is not that every AI interaction is harmful, but that repeatedly outsourcing these experiences could prevent people from developing the skills needed to manage difficult emotions independently.
Although chatbots can generate comforting responses, human relationships involve emotional reciprocity, shared experiences and accountability. Speaking to someone who genuinely cares can help people feel understood and navigate difficult situations.
“Human nervous systems settle in each other’s company. We call it co-regulation. A steady voice, a hand on a shoulder, the small pause of someone who is actually affected by what you are saying, all of it tells the body it is safe. A chatbot can produce warm words. It cannot be moved by yours,” Prakriti says.
She adds that real relationships require people to show up for one another, apologise after disagreements and make space for each other’s feelings. Unlike interactions with chatbots, human connections involve navigating differences and learning to respond to another person’s needs. “A bond where only one side has needs is comfortable, but also smaller,” she explains.
Prakriti recommends treating AI as a tool for reflection rather than allowing it to make personal decisions or replace human support. Before opening a chatbot for reassurance, take a few minutes to identify what you are feeling and consider your own perspective.
Instead of asking AI to tell you what to do, use it to explore different viewpoints and identify aspects of a situation you may have overlooked.
“Use AI to organise your thoughts, not to hand down verdicts. ‘Help me see what I might be missing’ works better than ‘Tell me what to do’,” Prakriti advises. She adds that if a chatbot agrees with everything you say, its response should not automatically be treated as validation that your interpretation is correct.
It is also important to recognise patterns of use. Repeatedly asking the same questions, consulting AI before every small decision, feeling more anxious after conversations or preferring chatbots to human interaction may indicate an unhealthy reliance.
Parents and teachers should approach young people’s use of AI with curiosity rather than judgment or immediate punishment.
“Many young people use these tools in private, so curiosity will get you further than confiscation. ‘What do you talk to it about?’ opens a door that ‘Give me that phone’ shuts,” Prakriti says.
She also stresses that persistent low mood, panic, trauma or thoughts of self-harm warrant support from a qualified mental health professional. In India, Tele-MANAS offers free, round-the-clock mental health support at 14416.
Rather than avoiding AI altogether, Prakriti encourages users to assess whether these interactions help them become more emotionally independent or make them increasingly reliant on the technology.
“Did I leave more able to talk to a person, make a choice or sit with this feeling? Or did I leave needing to come back?” she suggests asking after an AI conversation.
If the interaction helps you understand your feelings and communicate more confidently with others, it may be serving a useful purpose. If it leaves you repeatedly seeking reassurance or unable to make decisions without the chatbot, it may be time to reconsider how you use it.
AI can help people articulate emotions, explore perspectives and prepare for difficult conversations. However, emotional growth also requires learning to tolerate uncertainty, trust one’s judgement and navigate relationships with real people.
“We can let machines carry our shopping lists and our spreadsheets. Our griefs, our doubts and our friendships are different. They are the work through which a person gets made, and that work is worth keeping,” Prakriti concludes.
Note to readers: This article is for informational purposes only and not a substitute for professional medical advice. Always seek the advice of your doctor with any questions about a medical condition.
Akanksha Agnihotri is a lifestyle journalist with over 3 years of experience. She is a psychology graduate and holds a postgraduate diploma in Radio and Television Journalism from the Indian Institute of Mass Communication, Delhi, where she graduated as a gold medalist. Originally from Bhopal, the beautiful capital of Madhya Pradesh, she draws inspiration from the city’s rich cultural heritage and layered storytelling traditions that subtly shape her narrative voice. She writes extensively about fashion, beauty, health, relationships, culture, and food, exploring everything from trending styles and runway moments to wellness routines and mindful living. Passionate about meaningful and candid conversations, she enjoys interviewing celebrities, doctors, designers, and film personalities, diving into discussions on fitness, beauty, mental health, and everything fun in between. With a keen eye for trends and a thoughtful understanding of human behaviour, she brings depth, sensitivity, and authenticity to her stories, ensuring they resonate with a wide and diverse audience. When she’s not working, you’ll usually find her lost in a book, planning her next mountain trek, or mapping out spontaneous travel escapes. She loves discovering new authors, revisiting old favourites, and spending quiet afternoons in museums soaking in art, history, and culture. An avid bird-watching enthusiast, she finds joy in early morning walks, spotting rare birds, and reconnecting with nature. Whether sipping coffee while journaling her thoughts or exploring hidden corners of a new city, she constantly seeks inspiration in everyday moments that often turn into compelling story ideas.Read More

source

Scroll to Top